Estimated reading time: 12 minutes
Hi! I’m an older experienced dater (41 yr old lesbian) and have a higher body count than most people expect. These almost all happened between my mid 20s to 30s.
I’ve been regularly and rigorously tested for STIs and remain clear. I’m very fortunate. However, I’ve had my high body count thrown in my face by multiple partners recently. Despite showing them my multiple test results, and explain that’s long been in the past, they will insist that I must have something. Lately, I’ve stopped dating altogether. I’m tired of being shamed for a past that was to me, not something to be ashamed of, given it was consensual and enjoyable.
How could I approach this topic in the future should I try dating again?
What’s In A Number?
This one’s easy. Date less shitty people.
Ok, I realize this sounds like I’m being dismissive, but I’m serious. You’re framing this in such a way that it implies that this is an issue with you and you need to address it in some way that doesn’t trigger a shitty response from folks who have retrograde ideas about STIs, sexual risk and “purity”.
And it’s not. The issue are people who have a problem with your sexual history. They’re the one who suck, here.
Unless you’re dropping that info like a challenge, as a form of dominance or authority or some weird form of one-upmanship – and it certainly doesn’t sound like you are – then the question of “how to roll it out” really does make it sound like the issue is “how do I do this in a way that minimizes it” while tacitly accepting the frame that this is a bad thing – as though you should apologize for the sex you had or describe it in a way that makes it seem like having done it was a mistake.
Well… you shouldn’t. As you said: this was sex that you had that you consented to and that you enjoyed. That’s pretty much the end of the story as far as I’m concerned. You are 100% correct: this isn’t something to be ashamed of.
The number of people you’ve slept with isn’t really an indicator of anything than “the number of people you’ve slept with”. It’s value neutral, a data point in the sum totality of who you are as a person. It’s part of what made you the person you are today and, from the sound of it, you like that person. So the problem really isn’t how to roll it out to others, the problem is that the people you’ve been dating don’t like you. They like an idea of who you’re supposed to be in their heads. The person in front of them, not so much.
But here’s the thing: you’re not responsible for the person that folks think you should be, any more than you’re obligated to apologize for not being that person. You’re you. They can decide if they like you or not, number of sexual partners included, but that’s ultimately a them problem, not a you problem. The “you” problem in this case is letting shitty people stick around after they make it clear that they’re shitty.
And to be sure, folks can have opinions and preferences about the amount of sexual experience they want their theoretical partner to have. I’ve said many times: people are allowed to have whatever dealbreakers they want, regardless of what other people think. If someone wants to date a person who’s purer than the driven snow in Alaska, more power to ‘em. Other folks can have opinions about their dealbreakers, but they don’t get a vote.
But their having a dealbreaker doesn’t mean they get to be shitty about it to you or accuse you of things that are more about their issues than about you. Doubly so when they’re so wed to the idea that they’re throwing it back in your face regardless of the evidence. Evidence, like, say, negative test results for STIs.
Now, there are other choices, of course. You could lie about your number of former partners. It’s not like someone’s going to demand references or to see the official punch card or visitor ticker over your bed-frame; you could tell them with a straight face that you’ve only been with $ACCEPTABLE_NUMBER of people and just go from there. But if I’m being honest, I think that’s unnecessary and a mistake. I can understand the feeling of “well, a little white lie that helps people get over their bullshit at the start when they don’t know me”, but in my opinion if you feel like you have to conceal parts of yourself that don’t need to be concealed in order to date someone, then there’s a problem right from the jump. At best, I think this is just starting the clock on a time bomb that’s likely to go off.
On the other hand, you could just, y’know, not tell them. I don’t think the number of partners is important or even particularly revelatory. It can tell folks more about who you were at a particular time in your life, what your priorities were, what you valued and prioritized in relationships or connections with others… but I don’t think that’s something that needs to be shared, especially early on. Certainly not if someone is giving signs that they’re going to get weird about it.
Yes, having more partners means a greater risk of having been exposed to an STI. But that’s just life. Existence is a full-contact sport. Going skiing means accepting a greater risk of injury or death. Going out to eat means accepting a greater risk of food poisoning. Driving means risking life and limb. When we do these things, we do so with the tacit acknowledgement of the risks involved. It’s part of the whole deal and we don’t treat doing the acceptance of those risks as a sign of moral turpitude.
This is why, in my opinion, the only thing that someone’s really “entitled” to are the results of your STI screening, which is really the only part that’s any business of theirs. The rest can be filed under “none of your business”, or “I don’t kiss and tell”, “I don’t keep score”, “more than some, less than others”, or “enough to know what I like and who I want.”
There’re folks who will clearly take this as a sign that you’re hiding something or get pissy and demand actual numbers. But that says far more about them than it does about you and – again – it’s a them problem. You’re laying down a boundary that says “I don’t want to talk about it” with an unspoken “…yet”, “… if you’re going to act like this” or possibly even “…ever”. If they keep pushing and demanding to know, then they’re telling you valuable information about themselves. If you don’t want to share the number of people you’ve slept with and they get upset about it… well, that sounds like someone you probably shouldn’t be dating. If it’s that important, they’re free to go date someone who either has an acceptable number of former partners, or who wants to talk about it.
So my thought on how to handle it is: take it on a case by case basis, based on the person you date. You can lead off with a handwave that signals you’re not interested in talking actual numbers, or you can decide based on how they’ve acted so far. If she’s someone who’s shown that she’s not going to get weird and sex-shame-y about your romantic or sexual history, then hey, feel free to tell them if you want and feel secure in doing so. I’d say just be matter of fact about it, treating it like the data it is.
But if they’re getting judgey about it, or they throw it in your face? Then the only sensible thing to do is kick them to the curb and they can go find someone more to their liking. Because all that’s happened here is that they’ve demonstrated that they’re someone who is absolutely not right for you, and you’re better off without them. It’s certainly better than giving them any more of your valuable time, which they’ll just waste by being an asshole to you.
Your past is part of what makes you you. This includes your sexual history. This ain’t Build-A-Bear or a Baldur’s Gate character generator; they can’t customize your background to fit their idea of you. If they are going to object to your having a history like this, then they’re objecting to your whole self. It’s a package deal; you don’t get one without the other. You (and they) don’t need to dwell on it if nobody wants to, but it’s still just a fact of who you are.
If they have a problem with your number, they have a problem. But it’s not your problem. And if they can’t get over it and be a grown-up about it? Then they aren’t your problem either.
Good luck.
I was hanging out with some new friends of mine yesterday and we were having some drinks and joking around when one of them turned to me and said “You’ve never dated and it shows.” This kind of took me aback as I wasn’t expecting them to hit me with such a pointed and personal jab. It’s an accurate guess of course but then I got worried that I gave off “Virgin Energy” or something. I was just being my normal, goofy self so that got me worried that my default personality is unattractive or something. Am I overthinking this? Do I need to change how I act?
Big Maidenless Energy
I swear (every fuckin’ day), half my job would up and vanish if folks just had better friends.
This is just some asshat doing the guy thing of “bonding by roasting each other” who’s giving you shit and hit you in a sensitive spot.
I’m not necessarily against roasting or teasing among friends. Several of my friends and I will tease one another regularly when we hang out. But it’s not merciless teasing, it’s affectionate. Part of the unspoken agreement is that we avoid hitting the places we know would actually hurt and the overall vibe is that the joking is about an exaggerated and clearly not real version of the person. It’s never with the subtext that we believe it to be true; we joke because we know it’s not. Similarly, we’re just as quick to make similar jokes about ourselves because we all know we’re all ridiculous in all sorts of ways. It’s in-group joking and teasing, the sort that reaffirms that we’re all part of this together, and that we can do this because we know each other well and care about each other. And if it gets too real, we apologize and we stop.
This, on the other hand, sounds like someone trying to put you “in your place” as it were – mock you in such a way that it establishes you in the social hierarchy. That’s more the mark of an asshole, especially if they’re not someone who knows you well enough or is close enough to have the privileges that allow them to joke like that with you. If they’re doing it because they think it’s funny, but don’t intend to be mean, then they’re a boor. If they’re doing it knowing that you haven’t dated anyone and know it bothers you, then they’re an asshole. One is potentially correctable, the other is someone you probably shouldn’t waste more time on.
What I don’t think is that you need to change how you act, and I do think you’re overthinking things. Maybe you act around these guys in a way that seems stereotypically socially awkward, and the dude drew a conclusion. It’s certainly possible that you gave off “never dated before, ever” vibes like Steve Carrell trying to bluff his way through a conversation in The 40-Year Old Virgin and the guy picked up on it and weaponized it on you. But quite frankly, it’s much more likely that this was just variation #2302b of the standard “men who aren’t neck-deep in chicks are losers” insult and it just happened to be the truth. It’s akin to – again, referencing The 40-Year Old Virgin – someone riffing on “know how I know you’re gay?” except turns out the other person actually is closeted. Shotgun enough insults about someone’s lack of a sex-life out there and you’re more likely to score a hit eventually.
(Another possibility is that you told someone else in the group and word got around, and… well, assholes are gonna ass.)
Do you need to act differently? Well, let me ask you: are you carrying a chip on your shoulder about having little dating experience? Are you making “oh woe is me, I am among The Great Untouched and it’s not fair?” noises all the time? Are you trying to hide or obfuscate your relationship history? Because if the answer to any of that is “no”, then no, I really don’t think you need to change anything. Even if you are somehow pinging on people’s “haven’t gotten any” radar, the issue really isn’t that you’re pinging it so much as “why are you treating it like a big deal?”
And that really should be your response to it: “so?” or “And your point is?” Because it’s really not a big deal, no matter how much some slapdick tries to make it one. Not ceding the ground that this is something to be ashamed of or a mark against you makes it a lot harder to use it against you; it makes the other person look like an asshat for trying. It also makes it that much easier to spot the folks you shouldn’t spend time with because they’re demonstrating themselves to be a shithead and your time is too valuable to waste on shitheads.
Here’s the thing: being a virgin or having no relationship history is value neutral. As I’ve said many times before, being a virgin isn’t a measure of your worth or desirability as a person. It’s simply a marker of “have had this experience” or “haven’t had this experience” with no more meaning or significance than whether you’ve ever gone skydiving or seen the Grand Canyon. Any significance is arbitrary and what people make of it says more about themthan it does about that data point. And if they’re going to treat it as a negative? Then that marks them as an asshole rather than saying anything about you.
I can tell you from experience: having sex isn’t going to change you as a person. Losing your virginity won’t make you wiser, more mature, more cultured or anything else. If you were to go out tonight, run into the woman of your dreams and just absolutely wreck a hotel room and leaving it looking like a blacklight Jackson Pollock painting, you would wake up the next morning as exactly the same person you were the day before.
Nor, for that matter, would folks be able to magically detect the “just had sex” on you. There wouldn’t be some glow surrounding you telling everyone that you got your ashes hauled. The only way people would know is if you told them. So unless you’re making your sex life – or lack thereof – a big deal in those conversations? Then nobody’s going to know, and it’s not really their business anyway.
TL;DR: assholes are gonna ass and trying to avoid giving off “big virgin energy” is just going to come off like insecurity. Better to just treat it like the non-issue it is and be friends with a better class of people.
Good luck.

